Atlas / tournament documentation

Moot court and HSMCA

How Atlas runs a moot court tournament: the moot court preset and HSMCA's league template, the justices' ballot, how ballots count, optional clerks, and the setup a league like HSMCA uses for families and fees.

Moot court is an appellate argument: two advocates per side argue a case before a bench of justices. A courtroom clerk can keep time, though clerks are optional and the Moot Court preset starts with them off. Atlas runs it with the same screens as any other format. This page lists what is different and where each part is set. HSMCA is a league that runs moot court on Atlas, and the last section walks its setup.

The moot court presets

There is one moot court preset, Moot Court, which counts every ballot. HSMCA's league also has its own template, HSMCA Moot Court, which only HSMCA sees: Moot Court with the HSMCA rulebook, two justices a prelim courtroom, two counted ballots a prelim, and ranking on ballots. Choose in person or online with Venue format on the same form; the preset and the template are the same either way. Everything a preset sets stays editable in Setup. See Creating a tournament.

SettingMoot CourtHSMCA Moot Court
EventMoot Court, MOOT, or Varsity and Novice Moot Court with divisionsThe same
Advocates per side22
Ballot categories, per advocateKnowledge of Facts and Law, Response to Questions, Delivery and Decorum, Logical Argumentation, 50 to 100 eachThe same
A side's totalEach advocate's four scores averaged, then the two averages addedThe same
Speaker point range100 to 200100 to 200
Preliminary rounds44
Justices per prelim courtroom12
Justices per outround courtroom33
Ballots counted in a prelimAll seated2
Outround: an even panel drops one ballot by drawNoYes
A split roomTab desk decidesStays split, a ballot each
Rank onWinsBallots
Tiebreakers, in orderWins, total speaker points, adjusted speaker points, opponent strength, head-to-head result, coin flipBallots, competitor strength, point differential, opponents' competitor strength, opponents' point differential, coin flip
PacingLive paced, in person or onlineThe same
BreakTo 8To 8

Ranks follow from the scores: the ballot asks the justice for category scores, and the ranks come from the totals. The justice still chooses the winner. Change a category's name or range in Setup, Ballot. See Setup.

Justices

  • A justice is a judge. Justices sign up, are invited and are approved exactly as judges are. See Judge sign-up and invites.
  • The bench. Round judges in Rounds opens the round's own page, headed Bench on a moot court round. There the tab room sees each justice's answer for the round and can put people in the round's pool as Chief Justice, Justice or Courtroom Clerk. Auto-allocate prefers to seat a Chief Justice first in the courtroom, which makes them its chair. Without one, whoever holds the first seat is the chair. See Judge sign-up and invites.
  • Panel size. When every event is moot court, Setup, Rounds & break takes any panel size, even ones included: Judges per prelim room from 1 to 7, and each elimination round from 1 to 9. A tournament that mixes moot court with another format keeps odd sizes. Prepare next round seats the number in Judges per room, which starts at Judges per prelim room. Auto-allocate judges on the Rounds console seats Judges per prelim room in each prelim courtroom too.
  • Counted ballots. Each event sets how many of a courtroom's ballots count, in Setup, Standings, Counted ballots. Ballots counted in a prelim is All seated or 2. Outround: an even panel drops one ballot by draw, when Yes, counts three of a bench of four, and an odd bench counts every ballot. A new event counts every ballot; the HSMCA preset sets 2 and Yes. When more justices sit than ballots count, a random draw made when the bench is seated leaves the extra ballots uncounted, and the courtroom is decided once every counted ballot is in, whether or not the seat left off has voted; a ballot from that seat is kept and never counted. A change to the bench before any ballot is in can draw again, and once a ballot is in, a seat change that would move the draw is refused. The justices are not told whose ballot is left off; the tab desk sees those seats marked not counted. See Ballots.
  • Deciding the courtroom. A majority of the counted ballots decides it. When the counted ballots split evenly with every one in, the event's A split room setting decides. Tab desk decides leaves the courtroom for the tab desk, as any tied panel. Stays split, a ballot each makes it final with no winner, each side taking one ballot: the HSMCA rule. Higher points wins gives it to the side with the higher total team score across the counted ballots, each side still keeping its ballot, and equal points go to the tab desk. A change to these settings is refused once it would alter a courtroom whose ballots are in.
  • Ranking on ballots. The HSMCA preset ranks on ballots already. For an event from the general preset or created by hand, in Setup, Standings, set Rank on to Ballots for the event, and add competitor strength, point differential and the two opponents' measures with Add a tiebreak. See Standings.
  • The ballot. Each justice scores every advocate in each category, writes a reason for decision and comments, and submits. On a moot court event the ballot names the sides Petitioner and Respondent, and a printed ballot's signature line reads Justice signature. See Judges and justices.

Clerks

  • A clerk keeps time and gets no ballot. A person signs up as one by ticking Clerking only on the judge page, offered only when the tournament has a moot court event and Courtroom clerks is set to some rounds.
  • Clerks are optional and the Moot Court preset starts with them off. In Setup > Rounds & break > Courtroom clerks, choose the rounds that use them before the button in Rounds seats one clerk per courtroom. Preparing the next round seats judges but not clerks.
  • Clerks work from the clerk desk, which lists their assigned courtrooms, and time each courtroom from its room page. See Courtroom clerks.
  • The clerk desk depends on the event's format being Moot Court. A preset sets it; on a tournament created by hand, choose Moot Court as the event's format in Setup, Events.

Running an HSMCA tournament

HSMCA enters students by family and charges an entry fee. The steps below are the league setup plus one tournament. Each links to the full page.

  1. League setup, once. Finish the league's setup, set the logo, icon, colors and heading font on Branding, and choose Moot Court as the starting default. See League owners and admins.
  2. Families. Upload the family roster on Families with each family's code, name and contact email, and add each family's students and guardians under Members. A moot court entry is a team of two held as one entry, so a guardian names the partner when registering and the partner's family does not register them again. On Registrations the partner shows under the first student with their roster family, and Partner off roster lists teams whose partner is on no family of the roster. See Families and guardians and Registration and field.
  3. Payments. Connect Stripe on Billing so families pay by card. Until it reads Connected, the league collects the fee itself and marks entries paid. See Payments.
  4. Create the tournament from HSMCA's league template, HSMCA Moot Court, with Varsity and Novice divisions if both run, and Venue format set to Online for an online tournament. The template seats two justices in each prelim courtroom, counts two ballots a prelim and an odd number an outround, keeps a 1 to 1 courtroom split, and ranks on ballots. A tournament made from the general Moot Court preset or by hand gets the same rules by setting, for each event in Setup, Standings, Counted ballots to 2, Yes and Stays split, a ballot each, and Rank on to Ballots.
  5. Setup, Registration. Set the entry fee, turn on Only affiliated families may register, add any promo codes, and open registration when ready.
  6. Setup, Rounds & break and Standings. Set two justices a prelim room and three an outround, or one more of each so a ballot is drawn off. The HSMCA preset already ranks the event on Ballots, with competitor strength, point differential and the opponents' measures as tiebreaks, and sets its Counted ballots; check them in Standings. An event added later starts on the general settings, so set its Counted ballots too.
  7. Judges. Share the judge page, add justices by hand, or invite a justice to named rounds from Field or from a round's Bench page, then approve each. HSMCA runs without clerks, so Courtroom clerks stays at No rounds.
  8. Before each round, open its Bench page from Round judges in Rounds. Select Ask them to email everyone who has not answered, and name a Chief Justice where you want one.
  9. On the day, run check-in, rounds, ballots and standings as for any tournament. See Directors and tab staff.

Help us fix the docs